(716) 699-1065
5 E Washington Street, Ellicottville, NY 14731
Located next to the Red Apple Kwik Fill Gas Station!

The Finest Gourmet Cheese & Specialty Meats

Take your taste buds on a ride with the finest gourmet cheese and specialty meats from EVL Cheese Company in Ellicottville, New York. Our inventory is stocked with more than 225 cheeses with 100 being from around the world, as well as fresh cheese curd, salt rising bread, gourmet delicacies, cheese spreads and so much more.
Cheese - Specialty Meats

New York State Cheddar:     Other Aged Cheddar:

• Mild (Aged 3 months)

• Medium (Aged 6 months)
• Sharp (Aged 9 months) 
• X Sharp (Aged 12 months)
• 3 Year Aged Cheddar

• 6 Year Aged Wisconsin
• Tickler (Aged 2 years)
• Canadian Vintage (Aged 3 years)
• 2 Year Aged Canadian Black Diamond


Fresh Cheese Curd:

Our Cheese Curd comes in twice a week - Fresh from the COW!  Other flavors include Garlic & Pepper and Spicy Italian.  

Popular Cheeses:

• Humbolt Fog
• Goat Brie
• Smoked Hot Pepper
• Limburger
• Provolone
• Mozzarella
• Red Dragon
• Valdeon Blue
• Harlech
• German Swiss
• Smoked Gouda
• Irish Dubliner
• White Stilton with Mango & Ginger

Cheese Spreads:

• Old York Sharp Cheddar Spread
• Old York Horseradish Spread
• Old York Port Wine Spread
• Smoked Sharp Cheddar Spread
• Garlic Cheese Spread

• Garden Vegetable Cheese Spread
• Cheddar Bacon Cheese Spread
• Swiss Almond Spread
• Amish Country Limburger Spread


Specialty Meats:

• Beef Summer Sausage
• Margarita Pepperoni Stick
• Smoked Serrano Ham
• Prosciutto de Parma Monstero
• Busseto Pancetta
• Busseto Dry Salami with Black Pepper
• Busseto Spicy Chorizo
|• Busseto Dry Coppa



• Angelica Salt Rising Bread
• Torrey Gourmet Breads - Cuba Cheddar, Cuba Cheddar Garlic & Cinnamon

Maple Syrup Products:

• Sprague's Maple Farms™ Maple Syrup
• Sprague's Maple Farms™ Pancake Mix
• Sprague's Maple Farms™ Maple Cream
• Sprague's Maple Farms™ Maple Candy
• The Sap Shack local (Cuba, NY) Syrup


Customer Favorites:

• Lollipop Regular & Hot Pepper Jelly
• Spunky Sauce
• Arbor Hill Healthy Blueberry Preserves
• Divina Olives
• Old Timers' Horseradish Products
• Olive Oils
• Hot Sauces
• Nuts

Contact us in Ellicottville, New York, for the finest gourmet cheese, spreads, meats and more in the state of New York.